Pleasure & Play

The Sexiest Thing About Kink Might Be Giving Up Control

There is a particular kind of exhaustion that comes from being the person who always knows what needs to happen next.

It is not necessarily the exhaustion of doing everything yourself. It is the quieter exhaustion of being the person who remembers. The one who notices that the reservation needs to be made, that the appointment needs to be moved, that someone needs to call the plumber, that the groceries are running low, that the flight leaves at 7:15 and therefore everyone needs to leave the house at 5:30. At work, it might be making the decision everyone else is waiting for. At home, it might be carrying the invisible calendar of other people’s needs.

Then you get into bed, where you are theoretically supposed to stop thinking about all of that, and somehow you are still making decisions.

What do you want? What should we do? What feels good? What happens next?

Perhaps that is one reason the idea of giving up control can be so compelling.

Not because everyone secretly wants to be dominated. Not because a demanding life inevitably produces a desire for submission. The evidence for either of those claims is far too thin. But because there is something psychologically interesting about deliberately stepping out of the role of the person who has to decide.

Kink gives us an unusually vivid way of thinking about that experience.

And once you look at it that way, some of the stereotypes surrounding kink start to seem almost beside the point.


The difference between surrender and submission

When people hear “giving up control,” they often jump immediately to BDSM, and then from BDSM to submission. But those are not interchangeable ideas.

Kink is a broad category of consensual sexual interests and experiences that sit outside conventional sexual expectations. BDSM is one part of that landscape, encompassing practices and dynamics involving bondage and discipline, dominance and submission, and sadism and masochism. A person can be interested in kink without being interested in BDSM, and a person can enjoy a particular BDSM dynamic without wanting it to become a permanent part of their identity.

Submission is more specific still. It generally describes a consensual power dynamic in which one person gives another some degree of authority or control.

Giving up control, however, can be much smaller than that.

You might want your partner to decide what happens for the next hour. You might enjoy being told what to do in bed but have no interest in being submissive outside it. You might want to reverse your usual relationship roles for an evening. You might simply discover that being relieved of the responsibility of initiating is unexpectedly exciting.

None of those experiences requires you to adopt a label.

And there is an important distinction underneath all of them: surrender does not have to mean surrendering agency.

In fact, the opposite may be true.

You decide that this is what you want. You choose the person you trust with it. You negotiate the boundaries. You decide what is off limits. You retain the ability to stop.

The control has not disappeared. It has been deliberately transferred.

That is part of what makes consensual power exchange so different from coercion. The erotic experience depends on the existence of choice underneath it. Without choice, there is no surrender to speak of. There is simply a loss of control.

Sex therapist and kink educator Stefani Goerlich has made this distinction particularly well, arguing that “kink doesn’t require vinyl, only voices.”¹ The point is not the equipment or the visual vocabulary we have come to associate with BDSM. At its core, the dynamic is about negotiated power.

And that makes the psychology considerably more interesting than the clichés.


Why might letting go feel good?

There is a tempting story here: modern life is stressful, people are exhausted from making decisions all day, therefore they want someone else to take control in bed.

It is a good story.

It is also more certain than the science allows us to be.

There is currently no robust evidence showing that people with more stressful or responsibility-heavy lives are inherently more likely to seek sexual surrender. Nor should BDSM be casually described as a treatment for stress.

What research does show is that people who engage in BDSM sometimes describe the experience in surprisingly restorative terms. In a 2016 study examining BDSM as a recreational activity, participants reported associations with pleasure, freedom, adventure, self-expression and relaxation, with a large proportion specifically describing decreased stress.²

Experimental research has also begun looking at what happens physiologically during BDSM interactions. Small studies have examined cortisol and other biological systems involved in stress, reward and pleasure, finding changes across different participants and roles. A 2022 systematic review of the biological literature concluded that there are intriguing findings involving cortisol, endocannabinoids and other systems, but also emphasized how limited and heterogeneous the research remains.³⁻⁴

So the science does not justify the simple conclusion that stressed people want BDSM.

But it does give us something more interesting to think about.

One of the pleasures of deliberately handing over control may be the temporary suspension of responsibility. When someone else has agreed to take the lead, you are no longer required to anticipate the next move. You can pay attention to sensation, anticipation and the other person rather than monitoring the situation and deciding what should happen next.

That isn’t unique to sex. We pay for massages because we want someone else to take care of the mechanics. We go on vacations where somebody else has planned the itinerary. We hand the car keys to a trusted driver after a long day.

Erotic surrender adds intimacy and vulnerability to the equation.

You are not simply allowing someone else to make a decision. You are allowing someone else to see you in a state in which you are not managing the experience yourself.

For someone accustomed to competence, that can be its own kind of novelty.


There is no single “kinky personality”

It is also tempting to imagine that people who enjoy kink are fundamentally different from people who don’t.

Research doesn’t support a neat personality type.

Studies have found associations between BDSM interest and traits including openness to experience and sensation-seeking, but the relationships are neither simple nor strong enough to produce a psychological profile of “the kinky person.”⁵⁻⁶

That matters because sexual interests are often less fixed than we assume.

Someone may be adventurous sexually but conservative about relationships. Someone else may have a very conventional relationship and a surprisingly unconventional fantasy life. Someone may enjoy intense sensation but dislike power exchange. Another person may be fascinated by power exchange precisely because they have little interest in physical intensity.

Even fantasy itself is an unreliable shorthand for identity. Research into sexual fantasies has found that many fantasies people consider unusual are considerably more common than they realize, while what people fantasize about, what they want to experience and what they actually do remain separate questions.⁷

A fantasy does not necessarily demand a lifestyle.

And sometimes the most revealing part of a fantasy isn’t its literal content.

It is the feeling it produces.


What happens when you change the usual roles in a relationship?

This may be where the idea of surrender becomes most interesting for people in long-term relationships.

Couples develop patterns. Over years together, certain roles become almost invisible because they are so familiar. One person tends to initiate sex. One tends to plan dates. One is more decisive. One waits for the other to make the first move. One is more comfortable saying what they want.

These arrangements are not necessarily bad. Most couples have them.

But eroticism does not always thrive on familiarity.

Sometimes it thrives on contrast.

The person who is usually the planner can discover what it feels like to have nothing to plan. The person who is usually cautious can decide to follow. The partner who has always been waiting for instructions can suddenly become the one giving them.

And because this is happening inside an established relationship, something else changes too: your partner gets to encounter a version of you they don’t normally see.

That can be powerful.

Long-term intimacy has an odd tendency to make us extremely legible to one another. We know each other’s routines, reactions and preferences. We know how the other person behaves when they’re tired, annoyed, distracted or hungry. We know who will remember the hotel confirmation and who will forget to charge their phone.

Erotic surrender can introduce a little uncertainty back into that familiarity.

Not uncertainty about whether you are safe. Quite the opposite. The safety is what allows the uncertainty to become pleasurable.

There is a difference between not knowing what your partner will do next and not knowing whether your partner will respect your boundaries. The first can be erotic. The second is not a sexual dynamic anyone should have to negotiate themselves into tolerating.

This is why consent is not an administrative footnote to kink. It is part of the architecture that makes surrender possible.


And then there is the uncomfortable possibility of wanting this with someone else

Sometimes the fantasy does not stop at wanting to give up control.

It involves giving it up to a particular person.

That person may be a stranger, someone from the past, a colleague, an imagined character, or simply a type of person who represents a different dynamic from the one that exists at home.

This is where people can become unnecessarily alarmed by their own fantasies.

Being attracted to a particular dynamic outside your relationship does not automatically mean you want to leave your relationship. It may instead reveal something about the dynamic itself. Perhaps you associate that person with confidence. Perhaps they represent novelty. Perhaps, in your imagination, you get to become less responsible around them.

But it is also worth being honest about the distinction between fantasy and action.

Kink and consensual non-monogamy are not the same thing. Kink describes sexual interests and practices; consensual non-monogamy describes a relationship arrangement in which partners have explicitly agreed that sexual or romantic experiences outside the relationship are permitted. The two can overlap, and research among kink-identified adults has found that some people see consensual non-monogamy as one way of accommodating kink interests that may not fit comfortably within an existing relationship.⁸

But an agreed-upon outside relationship is fundamentally different from secretly pursuing one.

If a fantasy about another person keeps returning, the useful question may therefore be less “Should I do this?” and more “What exactly am I imagining?”

Is it the person?

Is it the power dynamic?

Is it the novelty?

Is it the experience of being wanted by someone who does not know your usual role?

Or is it the possibility of becoming someone slightly different yourself?

Sometimes the fantasy is telling you something about a need. That doesn’t necessarily tell you what you should do about it.


You can experiment without turning your bedroom into a costume shop

If the idea of surrendering control is intriguing, there is no requirement to begin with the visual vocabulary most people associate with BDSM.

You don’t need restraints. You don’t need pain. You don’t need an elaborate collection of equipment. And you certainly don’t need to imitate something you’ve seen online simply because it appears to be what “kink” is supposed to look like.

A much more revealing experiment can be almost boringly simple.

Choose one small area in which one partner gets to lead and the other agrees to follow. Decide the boundaries beforehand. Make the experiment temporary and reversible. Talk about what each person does and does not want. Establish a clear way to stop.

Then pay attention to what actually happens.

Does the person giving up control feel relieved? Does anticipation become more exciting? Does being directed feel intimate? Does the person taking control enjoy the responsibility? Does either person discover that they like the reversal more than expected?

Or does nothing much happen at all?

That answer is just as useful.

The point isn’t to perform kink correctly. It is to notice what happens when the usual distribution of control changes.


Maybe the most erotic part is that you can take it back

We tend to talk about sexual freedom as an expansion of choice. More possibilities. More experimentation. More partners. More novelty. More intensity.

But there is another kind of freedom that receives much less attention: choosing when you don’t want to be the person making the choices.

That is why the distinction between surrender and submission matters so much.

You can enjoy giving someone else control without wanting to live under someone else’s control. You can enjoy being led without wanting to be a submissive person. You can experiment with power without turning power exchange into your relationship structure. And you can discover that what excites you isn’t the loss of control at all, but the extraordinary intimacy of choosing someone you trust to hold it for a while.

Perhaps that is what makes surrender so paradoxical.

It can look like giving something away while actually requiring a very clear sense of what belongs to you.

Your boundaries. Your consent. Your choice. Your ability to stop.

The most interesting question, then, may not be whether you are kinky.

It may be whether there is a part of your life in which you are so accustomed to being in charge that you have forgotten what it feels like to let someone else take the wheel.

Not because you have to.

Not because you are submissive.

But because, sometimes, choosing not to be in control is itself a form of control.

And perhaps the sexiest thing about surrender is knowing that you are the one who gets to decide when to let go.

Sources

  1. Goerlich, S. “What We Mean When We Talk About Power Exchange.” Psychology Today, 2021.

  2. Holvoet, L. et al. “Is Bondage-Discipline, Dominance-Submission and Sadomasochism Recreational Leisure? A Descriptive Exploratory Investigation.” Journal of Sexual Medicine, 2016.

  3. Wuyts, E. et al. “Between Pleasure and Pain: A Pilot Study on the Biological Mechanisms Associated With BDSM Interactions in Dominants and Submissives.” Journal of Sexual Medicine, 2020.

  4. Wuyts, E. & Morrens, M. “The Biology of BDSM: A Systematic Review.” Journal of Sexual Medicine, 2022.

  5. De Neef, N. et al. “BDSM From an Integrative Biopsychosocial Perspective: A Systematic Review.” Sexual Medicine, 2019.

  6. Alanko, K. et al. “The Prevalence of BDSM in Finland and the Association between BDSM Interest and Personality Traits.” Journal of Sex Research, 2022.

  7. Joyal, C. C., Cossette, A. & Lapierre, V. “What Exactly Is an Unusual Sexual Fantasy?” Journal of Sexual Medicine, 2015.

  8. Vilkin, E. & Sprott, R. A. “Consensual Non-Monogamy Among Kink-Identified Adults.” Archives of Sexual Behavior, 2021.